Select the cognitive battery that best fits the student's language profile, age, and evaluation question. The matrix identifies the strongest option per scenario — battery snapshots and FIE documentation guidance follow below.
| Student / Evaluation Factor | KABC-II | Batería IV | WISC-V | WPPSI-IV | WJ-V COG |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Language Profile | |||||
| Spanish-dominant EB — Spanish stronger language | MPI/NVI; pair w/ Batería ACH | Primary choice | NVI only; limit verbal tasks | NVI if K–1; limit verbal | WJ V Nonverbal (NVCAI) if Spanish testing isn’t available; pair w/ Batería IV |
| Bilingual — roughly balanced, English emerging | MPI preferred; reduces Gc confound | Consider if Spanish norms better fit | GAI or NVI; avoid FSIQ | NVI or Gf if K–1 | Gc clusters separable; NVCAI as a cross-check |
| English-dominant — adequate conversational English | Normed on Spanish speakers | FSIQ appropriate; GAI if Gc low | If K–1 | ||
| Non-Spanish L1 (e.g., Vietnamese, Arabic, Amharic) | NVI or MPI — best fit | Spanish norms don't apply | NVI preferred | NVI if K–1 | WJ V Nonverbal (NVCAI); EL validation sample was mostly Spanish-speaking |
| Language dominance unclear / WMLS CLI inconclusive | MPI minimizes language load | Only if Spanish is clearly stronger | NVI; document rationale | NVI if K–1 | WJ V Nonverbal (NVCAI) minimizes language load |
| Age & Grade | |||||
| Kindergarten or 1st grade (ages 5:0–7:7) | Usable; WPPSI-IV often better fit | Batería IV starts at 5; check norms | WISC-V starts 6:0; WPPSI-IV preferred | Best fit; NVI & Gf subtests for CLD | Most tests from age 4; NVCAI and Gf need age 6 |
| Ages 6–16 (typical SLD age range) | WPPSI-IV tops out at 7:7; use WISC-V after | ||||
| Ages 17–18+ (transition, older reevals) | Norms extend to 18:11 | Check upper age norms | Norms to 16:11; WAIS-IV for 17+ | Not appropriate above 7:7 | Norms to 90+ |
| Evaluation Purpose | |||||
| SLD identification — C-SEP / PSW approach | Fully supports C-SEP; MPI for EB | CHC clusters align with C-SEP | Index scores map to CHC/C-SEP | Supports C-SEP for K–1 SLD | Strong CHC alignment |
| Intellectual Disability (ID) evaluation | FCI + adaptive; MPI if language confound | Pair with ABAS-3 Spanish or Vineland-3 | FSIQ primary; NVI supplemental | Age-appropriate but limited floor for severe ID | GIA primary |
| Student with significant language disorder (SI) | NVI — removes language demands entirely | Some subtests still require verbal response | NVI; note verbal subtest limitations | Avoid verbal composites | WJ V Nonverbal — validated with a language-impaired group |
| Autism (AU) evaluation — communication limitations | NVI — most language-reduced option | Verbal demands may be a confound | NVI or select index; note limits | NVI if K–1 | WJ V Nonverbal; demonstration format has its own social demand; AU L3 not in validation sample |
| CLD-Specific Considerations | |||||
| Minimal verbal response required | NVI uses only nonverbal subtests | Some subtests are nonverbal; others require Spanish | NVI achievable | NVI achievable | WJ V Nonverbal — video and gesture directions |
| Crystallized knowledge (Gc) likely suppressed by limited exposure | Luria/MPI excludes Gc entirely | Gc normed on Spanish-speaking sample | Use GAI (excludes WMI/PSI) or NVI; avoid FSIQ | Avoid VCI composites; use Gf or NVI | NVCAI excludes Gc; Gc clusters reported separately |
| Pairs with Spanish achievement battery | Pairs well with Batería IV ACH; cross-battery interpretation needed | Designed to pair with Batería IV ACH | Not designed as a pair | Not designed as a pair | Pair WJ V (English) with Batería IV (Spanish); separately normed — no WJ V Spanish edition yet |
| C-SEP documentation — language difference vs. disorder | MPI + NVI discrepancy helps isolate language from ability | Spanish norms strongest for ruling out language difference | NVI useful; document selection reasoning | NVI useful; document rationale | NVCAI vs. GIA/Gc contrast; never mix verbal and NV tests in the GIA |