Field Notes · October 2026 — The FIE - Cognitive Domain: Assessing the system’s ability to learn, solve, and remember.
← Back to Field Notes
The Diagnostic Series, Piece 2 · Barber Sped Hub · Shana Mikels-Barber, MEd · October 20, 2026 · ~25 min read

The Vacuum

On March 22, 2017, a unanimous Supreme Court ruling in Endrew F. v. Douglas County School District raised the substantive floor of special education law for the first time in 35 years. Since Rowley in 1982, that floor had been “some educational benefit.” Six federal circuits interpreted “some” so loosely that an IEP (an individualized education program) could pass legal muster by offering barely more than trivial benefit, as long as it was documented (U.S. Department of Education, 2017, Question 6). The legal term was “merely more than de minimis.” Endrew F. rejected that standard. An IEP must instead be reasonably calculated to enable progress appropriate to the child’s circumstances. For children who are not on track to advance grade by grade, the Court went further: their programs must be “appropriately ambitious,” because every child should have the chance to meet challenging objectives (Endrew F. v. Douglas County School District RE-1, 2017, p. 402). The most important word the Court has given disabled children in a generation is “ambitious.”

Then the Court did a second thing, and that is where this piece lives. It declined to define “ambitious.” No bright-line rule would emerge, and the absence of one “should not be mistaken for an invitation to the courts to substitute their own notions of sound educational policy” (Endrew F., 2017, p. 404, quoting Board of Education v. Rowley, 1982). The Court explained that deference “is based on the application of expertise and the exercise of judgment by school authorities” (Endrew F., 2017, p. 404). As a matter of jurisprudence, this is defensible; the Court cannot attend IEP meetings. However, look at what it actually hands down. Eight months later, the Department of Education issued its guidance in question-and-answer format, and the 13th question asks what practitioners needed to know: how can IEP teams determine whether annual goals are appropriately ambitious? The answer quotes the Court back to the reader, points to alignment with grade-level content standards, and cautions that alignment “must guide, and not replace” individualized decision-making (U.S. Department of Education, 2017, Question 13). The same guidance handed the baton down once more: state education agencies, it said, should review their policies and provide guidance to ensure that goals are appropriately ambitious (U.S. Department of Education, 2017, Question 19). Below the federal level, where guidance exists at all, it arrives with a chaperone. Maryland’s state education agency trains IEP teams that annual goals should reflect an “ambitious but achievable” amount of progress (Maryland State Department of Education, 2024, slide 13); the District of Columbia’s state education agency trains families on goals that are “appropriate, ambitious, and attainable” (Office of the State Superintendent of Education, n.d.). None of it supplies a definition. The pattern is the adjective plus a governor word, a hedge where a norm should be. Each handoff passed along the word and the responsibility to make it mean something — and kept neither. By the time the standard reached the conference table in an individual school, it was a mandate with no contents: the IEP team must be ambitious, and no one above them would say what that requires.

The most consequential judgment in a disabled child’s educational life is what counts as ambitious for this child, and it is delegated to whoever sits across the IEP table, filtered through whatever framework those officials absorbed from their training, their district’s culture, and their own unexamined assumptions. The law supplies the word; the people around the table supply the meaning. In a diagnostician’s terms: a standard with no norms. Every diagnostician knows what an un-normed instrument produces. It produces scores that measure the scorer.

The refusal to define is not a capacity problem, and the statute proves it. Federal education law defines ambition in exactly one place: the targets states set for themselves. The Every Student Succeeds Act requires each state plan to establish “ambitious State-designed long-term goals,” with numbers attached, and the Department reviews them (20 U.S.C. § 6311(c)(4)(A)). The IDEA, the same law that leaves a child’s goals to an undefined adjective, demands “measurable and rigorous targets” for every indicator in a state’s performance plan (20 U.S.C. § 1416(b)(2)(A)). The system operationalizes ambition annually, in writing, wherever the entity being measured is the system. It declines only where the entity being measured is a child.

This series evaluates the special education system the way the system evaluates children — using the same methodology, the same domains, and the same standard of evidence. The referral has been accepted; this is the cognitive domain: how the system learns, solves, and remembers, and before any of that, what it thinks with. When judgments vary this widely among identically situated children, an examiner does not evaluate the judgments one at a time; she evaluates the processes that produce them. The sections that follow identify the frameworks the special education system reasons with (there are four, and the system chose none of them deliberately), then norm-reference the profile and report findings. The oldest of the four has been running since before the system existed.

The Medical Model

Every framework the system thinks with locates the problem. The medical model locates the problem in the body. Through this lens, disability is a deficit within the individual: something gone wrong that assessment identifies and treatment corrects. Progress is measured against a single yardstick: how closely the person comes to functioning like everyone else. The lens is older than special education, and disabled people named it precisely so it could be seen. In 1975 — the same year Congress passed the Education for All Handicapped Children Act, the law that first guaranteed disabled children a public education — a group of British disabled activists calling itself the Union of the Physically Impaired Against Segregation (UPIAS) drew the distinction the field still uses. Impairment belongs to the body. Disability is imposed on top of it by a world organized as if that body did not exist (UPIAS, 1976). Michael Oliver, a disabled sociologist who became the UK’s first professor of disability studies, built that distinction into what he named the social model of disability. He then spent 3 decades documenting an uncomfortable pattern: the social model became widely cited but rarely put into practice, while the individual, medicalized view continued to govern how institutions actually made decisions (Hall, 2024; Oliver, 1983, 2013). Institutions learned to say the new words. They kept thinking with the old lens.

Special education inherited the lens at birth, and the eligibility process shows it most plainly. Eligibility requires two findings: a qualifying condition and an educational need resulting from it. However, the two prongs are not equal. A child with a documented need and no qualifying condition receives nothing; the need, however real, cannot open the door by itself. The condition is the gate, and for several categories, only a medical professional can open it. Families encounter this boundary constantly, usually without anyone naming it: a physician can diagnose a condition, but only the school’s team can determine educational eligibility, because the two systems answer different questions (Parent Educational Advocacy Training Center, 2020). Medicine asks what is wrong with this body. An evaluation asks what this student needs to learn. Those are different questions with different instruments, different data, and different consequences. Yet for most of the system’s history, a school could not answer the second question without a doctor first answering the first. This section documents that leftover requirement: medical paperwork standing between a child and an educational service.

Texas wrote the medical requirement directly into its administrative code — and has been visibly removing it, on the record. Until the summer of 2024, a Texas student could not be found eligible as deaf or hard of hearing without an otological examination performed by an otolaryngologist or, when one was not reasonably available, another licensed medical doctor: a physician’s report standing as the gate to an educational service. Effective July 30, 2024, and in response to a stakeholder petition, the requirement was removed from the rule. What replaced it is worth reading closely: an audiological evaluation performed by a licensed audiologist, and a communication assessment completed by the multidisciplinary team (19 Tex. Admin. Code § 89.1040, 2026; Texas Education Agency, 2024). A physician’s examination gave way to a functional question the educational team answers itself: how does this student communicate, and what does that mean for instruction? The residue is not gone. Orthopedic impairment and traumatic brain injury still require a medical diagnosis provided by a licensed physician; other health impairment still requires a licensed physician, physician assistant, or advanced practice registered nurse to identify or confirm the health problem; and visual impairment still requires a medical report from a licensed ophthalmologist or optometrist (19 Tex. Admin. Code § 89.1040(c)(7), (c)(8), (c)(11), (c)(12), 2026). When the rule was amended again in 2026, a commenter asked the agency to reduce its reliance on medical diagnosis for visual impairment; the agency declined to change the text, saying only that it would seek further stakeholder feedback (Texas Education Agency, 2026). Still, the direction of the edit is itself a finding. When Texas modernizes an eligibility rule, it removes the medical gate and adds educational data. The code is asserting which lens belongs.

The lens matters to this domain because a framework is not what a system does; it is how a system decides. Point the medical lens at Endrew’s question and “appropriately ambitious” acquires both a definition and a ceiling: ambitious means closer to normal, and the ceiling is the non-disabled peer. Educational goals written through this lens are remediation (fix what is broken, close the gap to typical), and the question they never ask is the one education exists to answer: what could this particular child learn, do, and become? Those are not two phrasings of the same ambition. They point toward different futures, and the person who explained the difference did it from inside the system’s own enforcement office. This evaluation turns to him next.

The Ableist Ceiling

Thomas Hehir is not an outside critic. He directed the U.S. Department of Education’s Office of Special Education Programs, the office that enforces IDEA, after running special education for the Boston public schools and serving as associate superintendent in Chicago. When Hehir describes what is wrong with the system’s thinking, it is the system’s own former enforcement chief testifying about what he watched the machinery do. That standing matters here the way a source’s vantage point matters to any evaluation: this is not a parent report or an advocate’s brief. It is the program administrator walking into the IEP meeting room and naming the problem himself.

What he called “ableism” does not sound like what you expect. From an ableist perspective, Hehir wrote, “the devaluation of disability results in societal attitudes that uncritically assert that it is better for a child to walk than roll, speak than sign, read print than read Braille, spell independently than use a spell-check, and hang out with nondisabled kids as opposed to other disabled kids” (Hehir, 2002, p. 3). Read the list slowly. Every preference in it sounds like common sense: of course we want the child to walk, to speak, to read print. That is precisely the finding. Ableism, as Hehir defines it, is not outright cruelty and rarely announces itself as low expectations. It is an unexamined preference for the normal, held by people who care about the child, doing its work through the word “uncritically.” Nobody in the room decided the ceiling. The lens set it before the meeting started.

The IEP consequence follows directly, and it is a budget problem. A school day has a fixed number of hours; a childhood has a fixed number of school years. When goal-writers’ unexamined ambition is to approximate the normal, the child’s hours are spent drilling the disability-specific deficit to close the distance to typical, and everything else an education is for gets crowded out. Hehir’s research documented the pattern across populations: students whose access to content, efficient disability-specific methods, and their own futures were postponed indefinitely in favor of becoming more like everyone else (Hehir, 2002, 2005). The goal is met or not met; either way, the work was remediation. The question no one wrote down — what could this particular child learn, do, and become — was never assigned any hours at all.

Hehir then made the claim that converts a philosophy critique into an outcome hypothesis. He made it with an evaluator’s caution: “The pervasiveness of ableist assumptions in the education of these children not only reinforces prevailing prejudices against disability but may very well contribute to low levels of educational attainment and employment” (Hehir, 2002, p. 4). Note the hedge: “may very well contribute.” He does not overclaim; he states a mechanism and a plausible effect, the way a careful examiner writes an interpretive summary. That modesty makes the claim durable. Twenty-plus years of outcome data later, the attainment and employment gaps persist, and the hypothesis has never been ruled out — because, as the referral documented, the system stopped collecting the data that could rule it out.

The medical lens, read through Hehir, explains the ceiling. It does not explain the paperwork. Ableism accounts for why goals aim low; it cannot by itself account for why the low goals are so uniformly formatted, so procedurally immaculate, so reliably copied forward — why the system’s failures arrive in triplicate with every signature line complete. For that, the evaluation needs a second lens, one that asks not what the system believes about disability but what the organization needs from its own routines. That lens has a name too, and it was pointed at special education 2 years before Hehir took over enforcement.

The Industrial Lens

Where Hehir named a belief, Skrtic named a structure. Thomas Skrtic is an organizational theorist who spent his career asking a question most special education scholarship never thinks to ask: not what is wrong with the child, and not what is wrong with the adults’ attitudes, but what kind of organization is a school — and what does that kind of organization do with a student who does not fit its work? His answer, developed through the field’s most sustained organizational analysis, is that public schools are built to implement standardized programs, not to solve novel problems: they package instruction into programs, deliver them at scale, and measure themselves by throughput (Skrtic, 1991). An organization built this way has exactly one move available when a student and a program do not match. It does not redesign the program; redesign is the one thing a standardized workflow cannot do locally. It routes the student. Special education, on this reading, is not the system’s accommodation of difference; it is the routing mechanism that lets the rest of the system stay standardized. Read that way, it is also the system’s standing admission that its standard program cannot flex and must be routed around.

The inversion that follows is the most radical claim in this evaluation’s source base, and the evaluation does not need all of it. Skrtic’s full argument is that much of what schools certify as disability, particularly in the mild, judgment-dependent categories, is an artifact of the organization itself: the collision between a standardized program and a non-standard learner, certified as pathology and relocated (Skrtic, 1991). A reader need not accept that claim in full; the categories diagnosticians work with are real, measurable, and consequential. The weaker version is sufficient and observable in any campus hallway: programs do not adapt to students; students are routed to fit programs. Whether the routing creates the disability or merely collects it, the direction of motion is the same — the child moves, the program does not.

The industrial model is usually invisible because it is ambient. Occasionally the design intent is written down. Texas now offers districts a state-developed elementary curriculum, Bluebonnet Learning, and describes its virtues in its own review materials: pacing guides for every instructional calendar, and resources to help administrators and instructional coaches implement the materials as designed (Texas Education Agency, n.d.). The goal is consistency: the same lesson, delivered the same way, on the same day, auditable at the door. The state presents the scripted format as a way to move teachers’ time from planning to instruction (Edison, 2025). A consistent schedule is a specification, and the child who cannot keep pace does not register as information about that pace. The child registers as a defect — and in this system, the paperwork that moves a defect out is called a referral.

If this were a uniquely American problem, another country’s paperwork would look different. It does not. England rebuilt its framework around needs. The settlement that followed the 1978 Warnock Report replaced categories of handicap with statements of need (Warnock, 1978), the genuinely different processing style this evaluation’s normative section will credit. England then watched compliance logic corrupt the framework from the inside. Research on exclusion in the post-Warnock system documents the pattern: an accountability architecture that rewards schools for performance creates perverse incentives to move students whose needs threaten the metrics, and the moving is done with the framework’s own instruments (Daniels et al., 2019). The finding matters here for what it removes. It removes the comforting hypothesis that better-designed forms produce better-behaved organizations. A performance organization will metabolize whatever framework it is handed (categories or needs, scores or statements) into its existing logic of throughput and routing. The framework does not change the organization; the organization digests the framework.

This is the second lens the previous section asked for, the one that explains the paperwork. In an organization that runs on routine, a mandate is metabolized into procedure, and the procedure — forms, timelines, signature lines, all complete — becomes the product. Compliance is what the organization can manufacture at scale; ambition is not, so ambition drops out of the product specification. Point this lens at Endrew’s question and “appropriately ambitious” acquires its second definition and its second ceiling: ambitious means whatever we can document, and the ceiling is whatever fits the form. The obvious objection is that the field has visibly reformed: a goal written today looks nothing like a goal written in 1995, and the difference is real. The objection is correct. Conceding it fully, and precisely, is the next section’s work, because only a proper concession makes it possible to see what the reforms touched and what they never reached.

The Verb Shift

This evaluation now concedes something the system did well, as it has twice before in this series, and this concession is the largest of the three. The field genuinely fixed the verbs. A goal written in 1995 might promise that a student would “improve reading comprehension” or “develop grade-level math skills,” goals with nothing to measure, nothing to measure against, and no way to ever call them unmet. A goal written today names an observable behavior, sets a criterion, references a curriculum standard, and specifies measurement conditions. That change was not an accident. It was taught: the 1997 reauthorization mandated access to the general curriculum; the 2004 reauthorization aligned IDEA with the accountability logic of No Child Left Behind; a November 2015 Dear Colleague letter from the Department’s Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative Services told the field plainly that annual goals must align with the state’s grade-level content standards (U.S. Department of Education, Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative Services, 2015); and Endrew raised the substantive bar 2 years later. Four instructional prompts across 2 decades, and the field’s goal-writing responded to every one. Concede it fully: on the skill it was explicitly taught, the examinee — the American special education system — shows acquisition.

Now watch what kind of learning it is. A curriculum-aligned verb constrains how a goal is written, not where the ceiling is set. A goal can be fully standards-aligned in form and fully medical-model in ambition: “given a third-grade passage, the student will identify the main idea with 80% accuracy” is observable, measurable, criterion-referenced, and standard-coded. If the child sits in a seventh-grade classroom, it is also a remediation project pointed four grade levels behind, immaculately documented. The verb answers one question: is this measurable? The lens answers the other: measured against what future? The reforms of 1997 through 2017 disciplined the first question and never touched the second. That is the vacuum this piece has been circling. The field standardized the grammar of ambition and left the ambition itself to whoever sits across the table.

A harder reading exists, and the evaluation is obligated to record it. Goal banks and IEP software now auto-generate standards-aligned language: a drop-down menu supplies the verb, the standard code, and the criterion in one motion. The reform meant to force intentionality, to make the goal-writer stop and specify, can now be produced by template at scale, without anyone stopping at all. That is the industrial lens doing exactly what the previous section said it does: absorbing the new requirement into routine and continuing to produce whatever the routine produces. The Court had insisted that “an IEP is not a form document” (Endrew F., 2017, p. 400). The form document did not become less common when the verbs improved; it became better formatted, the IDEA’s long emphasis on procedure over substance surviving the reform intact (Turnage, 2020). Acquisition without transfer is a profile every diagnostician recognizes — the skill performs on demand and changes nothing downstream.

What still discriminates between lenses, now that verbs no longer do, is a short list of ambition markers, and every one is visible on the face of the IEP. First, the distance between the standard a goal references and the child’s enrolled grade level: alignment to a standard is not ambition if the standard sits 4 years behind the child’s desk. Second, whether goals materially change from year to year or merely increment. Endrew’s own record is the canonical case: the same basic goals carried from one year to the next through fourth grade, with the numbers adjusted (Endrew F., 2017). Third, what the mastery criteria and conditions reveal about the plan’s theory of the child: whether the plan changes the child, or changes the child’s access. Fourth, whether the trajectory described in the present levels actually connects to the destination the goal implies, or whether the two documents merely share a page. Fifth — the marker that contains the other four — whose future the goal points toward: the further education, employment, and independent living that § 1400(d) names as the statute’s purposes, or the form’s next annual review. Verbs stopped discriminating the day software learned to write them. These five have no drop-down menu.

One more place ambition hides deserves a brief word before the frameworks are laid side by side. Educators are taught Bloom’s taxonomy as a hierarchy of thinking (Anderson & Krathwohl, 2001); in practice it can operate as a permission structure, with lower levels treated as prerequisites for higher ones, so that a weakness in an entry-level skill becomes the documented rationale for withholding analysis, evaluation, and creation. The verbs answer “is this measurable?”; the misread hierarchy answers “which verbs is this child allowed?” Hold both questions. The next section puts all four frameworks in a single table and asks them the only question that matters — what is appropriately ambitious for this child — because by now the answer should be predictable: it depends entirely on which lens is doing the reading.

The Lens Matrix

The evaluation can now do what it has been building toward: ask all four frameworks the same question and put the answers side by side. The question is Endrew’s — what is appropriately ambitious for this child? Ask the medical lens and the answer is closer to normal; the ceiling is the non-disabled peer. Ask the industrial lens and the answer is whatever we can document; the ceiling is whatever fits the form. Ask the social and ecological lens, the one the field cites fluently and rarely uses, and the answer is whatever the environment must change for this child to participate; the ceiling comes off the child entirely and lands on the setting. Ask the educational lens and the answer is whatever prepares this child for further education, employment, and independent living, the three destinations the statute itself names (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A)). Four frameworks, four answers, and the first two, the two the preceding sections found running the system, are the only two that set their ceilings on the child. Table 1 sets the four answers side by side.

Table 1

Four Lenses Asked Endrew’s Question

LensWhere it locates the problemWhat “appropriately ambitious” meansWhere the ceiling sits
MedicalA deficit within the child’s bodyCloser to normalThe non-disabled peer
IndustrialThe mismatch between the child and a standardized programWhatever can be documentedWhatever fits the form
Social and ecologicalBarriers in the environmentWhatever the environment must change for this child to participateOff the child; it lands on the setting
EducationalWhat this child needs to learnWhatever prepares this child for further education, employment, and independent livingNot set on the child; the destination is the adult life the statute names

Note. Each lens is asked the question from Endrew F. v. Douglas County School District RE-1 (2017). Answers are this evaluation’s synthesis. The medical and social distinction follows UPIAS (1976) and Oliver (1983); the industrial lens follows Skrtic (1991); the educational lens draws on 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A).

The matrix also corrects how Endrew’s word is usually argued. “Appropriately ambitious” gets litigated as a question of degree: how much progress is enough. Lay the four answers side by side, and it becomes clear that degree is the second question. The first is direction. Four lenses point a goal at four different futures: the normal child, the completed form, the changed environment, the adult life the statute describes. You cannot measure how far a goal travels until you know which way it is pointed — and the pointing is done, silently, before the first draft of the goal is written.

Now the quiet finding at the center of the piece. The educational lens is not a scholar’s import or a reformer’s proposal. It is the statute’s own first page, read literally: the first stated purpose of the IDEA is to ensure that children with disabilities receive an education “designed to meet their unique needs and prepare them for further education, employment, and independent living” (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A)). The framework the system should be thinking with has been in its founding document all along. The vacuum this piece opened with is therefore not an absence of guidance. It is an absence of assignment. Compliance offices audit procedure; courts defer on substance; and no office anywhere in the system is tasked with enforcing a philosophy — so the philosophy defaults, meeting by meeting, to whoever sits across the table.

This is also where the evaluation’s method closes its own loop. The referral committed this series to a criterion standard: the system measured against its own stated purpose, not against perfection. The matrix supplies the criterion: § 1400(d) is the reference point, and the finding is that the examinee reasons with every framework except the one it wrote down. A criterion, though, tells the evaluation what to measure against; it does not establish whether the result is unusual. For that, an evaluation needs a norm group.

The Normative Sample

No score means anything by itself. A processing speed index is not slow unless it is slow relative to same-age peers; a fluid reasoning weakness is not a weakness unless the norm group demonstrates that the task is developmentally attainable. The same requirement applies here. Before interpreting the system’s cognitive profile, the evaluation has to establish what same-age systems do when administered the same tasks.

The record supplies a controlled administration. Within 36 months in the 1970s, three systems of comparable age and resources sat for the same item: what should a public education system do about the children it had been excluding? The United States answered in 1975 with a parallel procedural system: eligibility categories, individualized documents, due process. Italy answered in 1977 by abolishing its special classes and placing nearly every child in the general education classroom (Legge 4 agosto 1977, n. 517). The United Kingdom answered in 1978 by discarding diagnostic categories in favor of a continuum of “special educational needs,” the Warnock Report’s insistence that the lens itself was the problem (Warnock, 1978). Same item, three processing styles: build a separate track, remove the tracks, rename the construct. None of the three answers was self-evidently right. What matters diagnostically is that the item could be answered more than one way — which means the American answer was a choice, not a constraint.

The contemporary administration is more striking, because it is happening now. In 2026, England’s system presented with the same symptom cluster documented in this evaluation’s referral: identification rising sharply, funding under severe strain, disputes turning adversarial. Families now file more than 8 times as many appeals against the system’s decisions as they did in 2015 (Long et al., 2026, p. 25). England’s response, published in February 2026, was a white paper (a formal statement of planned policy) proposing a redesigned tiered support structure, support plans a child can access without a diagnosis, and a multibillion-pound investment in mainstream inclusion. The proposal went to public consultation and is committed to legislation: the Education for All Bill, announced in the May 2026 King’s Speech, with transitional protections phased through the early 2030s. Existing plans stay in place, and no changes to existing statutory support begin before September 2030 (Department for Education, 2026a, 2026b; Long et al., 2026). Finland, meanwhile, has run tiered support (escalating levels of help) as universal pedagogy for more than a decade. The first two tiers are open to any student with no eligibility determination required, the same tiered construct the American system wrote into law in 2004 and, as documented in the referral, absorbed into a gatekeeping delay (Björn et al., 2016).

Candor requires that the norm group be normed honestly. England is not a success story. The white paper exists because England’s system of special educational needs and disabilities (SEND, the umbrella construct the Warnock renaming produced) is in acknowledged crisis, and disability advocates there warn that the reform may restrict rights to contain costs (Disability Rights UK, 2026). Before the white paper appeared, a parent-launched petition carrying that warning gathered more than 130,000 signatures and forced a parliamentary debate in which more than 90 MPs took part, and the white paper itself slipped into 2026 (Disability Rights UK, 2025; Learning Disability Today, 2025). Both systems face the same fiscal temptation. The comparison is not outcome-against-outcome. It is process against process. In the same year, presented with the same novel problem, one same-age system produced a written framework, opened its reasoning to public consultation, and committed to legislation with transitional safeguards. The other spent the same months interrupting and partially restoring the instruments that monitor its own results: the dropped studies and stale data this evaluation documents below. One system tried the new problem and may get parts of it wrong; the other declined to try. Any teacher — any parent — knows those are different problems. Every evaluator knows this formally: the student who attempts the novel item and errs, and the student who will not pick up the pencil, do not receive the same score, nor the same interpretation.

One more observation belongs in the record: the peer systems can be observed examining their own lens. England’s Parliament publishes unflattering briefings about its own system; its committees run inquiries with the word “crisis” in the title (House of Commons Education Committee, 2025). Whatever else that is, it is metacognition: a system thinking about its own thinking, in public, on the record. The American system has no equivalent instrument. In no scheduled setting has anyone administered the question this piece asks: what framework governs the system’s judgment? That absence is not incidental to this evaluation. It is why the referral had to be filed from the field.

(The international record receives fuller treatment in The Policy Landscape series; here it serves as what it is in any evaluation: the norm group.)

Interpretation of Cognitive Findings

What follows deliberately applies the diagnostician’s interpretive frame, reading the evidence above the way an evaluator reads an index profile built on the Cattell–Horn–Carroll abilities (Schneider & McGrew, 2018). The reading is analytic, not literal, and now that the norm group is established, it is comparative. The system has no brain. It has a pattern, and every diagnostician has written one up.

Its crystallized knowledge is intact — arguably exceptional. Fifty years of statute, regulation, case law, and procedure constitute an accumulated store of acquired knowledge that no one disputes. Ask the system what it knows, and it answers fluently with definitions, timelines, safeguards, and citations. The store is deep, well-organized, and instantly retrieved. On any measure of what has been learned, the system performs in the superior range.

Its fluid reasoning is another matter. Presented with a novel problem, a reform it has not seen before, a population its categories do not fit, a mandate its routines do not cover, the system does not reason through the novelty. It retrieves a rehearsed routine and applies it: add structure, add monitoring, add documentation, rename, recode, continue. The absorption pattern documented in the referral is not a character flaw; it is a processing profile. When the task is familiar, performance is strong. When the task requires generating a genuinely new response, the system reverts to the old one and reformats it.

Its processing speed tells its own story, and the contrast is not subtle. This system times its evaluators to the day. Federal law requires a full individual evaluation within 60 days of parental consent unless a state sets its own timeline (20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(C)). Texas set its own, requiring the written report by the 45th school day after the district receives signed consent (Tex. Educ. Code Ann. § 29.004, West 2026), and the evaluator who misses the deadline is out of compliance. The system’s own reevaluation has not been convened in 22 years; Congress last reauthorized the statute in 2004. Same-age systems completed multiple full revision cycles in the same window, and England is currently redesigning a framework it considers outdated at 12 years old (Children and Families Act 2014). The examiner is timed. The examinee, it turns out, is untimed.

And its working memory, the capacity to hold information in mind long enough to use it, shows a genuine weakness. The National Longitudinal Transition Study, the federal study built to track what happens to students with disabilities after high school, was dropped mid-collection in February 2025 when the Department canceled its research contracts; the work resumed 7 months later (Institute of Education Sciences, 2025). The nation’s most recent complete count of what special education actually costs still rests on data from the 1999–2000 school year; the successor study, commissioned a quarter century after the first, is still in progress (Chambers et al., 2002; Institute of Education Sciences, n.d.). The Government Accountability Office, meanwhile, found that the Department had stopped updating its public list of institutions under investigation after January 2025, even as the civil rights caseload kept growing by roughly 98 cases a week (U.S. Government Accountability Office, 2026). This is a system that cannot hold its own data in mind long enough to reason with it, which may be the simplest explanation for why the reasoning never improves.

Compared with same-age systems administered the same tasks, the profile is familiar: strong crystallized knowledge, weak fluid reasoning, slow processing, weak working memory. Every diagnostician has met this learner. It is the student who performs beautifully on rehearsed material and collapses when the problem is novel. Who compensates with routine so effectively that the compensation is mistaken for competence. Whose output looks fine on paper while comprehension has quietly stalled — and who has been passed along, year after year, because the paperwork was always complete.

An interpretation, though, never ends at the deficits. A learner with this profile does not need more content knowledge; it has plenty. It needs explicitly taught strategies it cannot generate on its own. It needs an environment modified to stop rewarding the compensation. It needs goals that someone actually holds it to, monitored on a schedule with consequences attached. Which is to say: a learner with this profile needs an individualized program, ambitiously written and honestly reviewed. What such a program would require comes later in this evaluation, where it belongs. The domains have to be completed first.

Close

The cognitive domain is complete. The examinee knows the material: 50 years of statute, regulation, and procedure, intact and retrievable on demand. It struggles to generate a novel response when the rehearsed one no longer works. It times everyone but itself. It cannot hold its own data in mind long enough to act on it. And beneath the index scores sits the domain’s central finding: the examinee has four frameworks available for deciding what a child’s education is for. It defaults to the two that set ceilings on the child, cites a third without using it, and has yet to be observed reasoning with the one written into its own founding statute — a capability present, printed, public, and unused.

How a system thinks, though, is only a hypothesis about what it will do. The next domain of this evaluation examines the product (what the system actually writes, delivers, and measures for children) and whether the output matches this cognitive profile the way an evaluator would predict. The domain closes. The evaluation continues.

What Is Coming in the Diagnostic Series

Piece 3 — The FIE - Academic Achievement and Functional Performance. What the system actually produces, and the 50-year gap between what IDEA promises and what children receive.

Piece 4 — The FIE - Ecological Domain. What the environment permits the system to do.

Piece 5 — The FIE - Behavioral Domain. What the system’s maladaptive behaviors accomplish, and what keeps them in place.

Piece 6 — The FIE - Conclusions and Recommendations. What the evaluation found, and what an appropriately ambitious program would require — published on a schedule that answers to the argument, not the news cycle.

Shana Mikels-Barber, MEd Texas Educational Diagnostician · Creator, Barber Sped Hub The views expressed here are my own and do not represent those of my employer.

References

  1. Anderson, L. W., & Krathwohl, D. R. (Eds.). (2001). A taxonomy for learning, teaching, and assessing: A revision of Bloom’s taxonomy of educational objectives. Longman.
  2. Björn, P. M., Aro, M. T., Koponen, T. K., Fuchs, L. S., & Fuchs, D. H. (2016). The many faces of special education within RTI frameworks in the United States and Finland. Learning Disability Quarterly, 39(1), 58–66. https://doi.org/10.1177/0731948715594787
  3. Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982).
  4. Chambers, J. G., Parrish, T. B., & Harr, J. J. (2002). What are we spending on special education services in the United States, 1999–2000? (Special Education Expenditure Project). American Institutes for Research. https://www.air.org/sites/default/files/SEEP1-What-Are-We-Spending-On.pdf
  5. Children and Families Act 2014, c. 6 (UK). https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2014/6/contents
  6. Daniels, H., Thompson, I., & Tawell, A. (2019). After Warnock: The effects of perverse incentives in policies in England for students with special educational needs. Frontiers in Education, 4, Article 36. https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2019.00036
  7. Department for Education. (2026a, February 23). Every child achieving and thriving (CP 1508-I) [White paper]. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/every-child-achieving-and-thriving
  8. Department for Education. (2026b, February 23). SEND reform: Putting children and young people first [Consultation]. https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/send-reform-putting-children-and-young-people-first
  9. Disability Rights UK. (2025, October 23). Schools white paper pushed back to 2026. https://www.disabilityrightsuk.org/news/schools-white-paper-pushed-back-2026
  10. Disability Rights UK. (2026, February 24). DR UK’s response to the Schools White Paper. https://www.disabilityrightsuk.org/node/4801
  11. Edison, J. (2025, August 28). 1 in 4 Texas school districts sign up for new Bible-infused curriculum. The Texas Tribune. https://www.texastribune.org/2025/08/28/texas-schools-bluebonnet-bible-curriculum/
  12. Endrew F. v. Douglas County School District RE-1, 580 U.S. 386 (2017).
  13. Every Student Succeeds Act, 20 U.S.C. § 6311(c)(4)(A) (2015).
  14. Hall, M. C. (2024). Critical disability theory. In E. N. Zalta & U. Nodelman (Eds.), The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (Fall 2024 ed.). Stanford University. https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2024/entries/disability-critical/
  15. Hehir, T. (2002). Eliminating ableism in education. Harvard Educational Review, 72(1), 1–32. https://doi.org/10.17763/haer.72.1.03866528702g2105
  16. Hehir, T. (2005). New directions in special education: Eliminating ableism in policy and practice. Harvard Education Press.
  17. House of Commons Education Committee. (2025, September 18). Solving the SEND crisis (HC 492). https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm5901/cmselect/cmeduc/492/report.html
  18. Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d) (2004).
  19. Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(C) (2004).
  20. Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, 20 U.S.C. § 1416(b)(2)(A) (2004).
  21. Institute of Education Sciences. (n.d.). National Study of Special Education Spending. https://ies.ed.gov/use-work/evaluations/national-study-special-education-spending
  22. Institute of Education Sciences. (2025). National Longitudinal Transition Study 2012 (NLTS 2012). https://ies.ed.gov/use-work/evaluations/national-longitudinal-transition-study-2012-nlts-2012
  23. Learning Disability Today. (2025, September 16). SEND debate: Let’s end the parent blame and solve the crisis. https://www.learningdisabilitytoday.co.uk/news/send-debate-lets-end-the-parent-blame-and-solve-the-crisis/
  24. Legge 4 agosto 1977, n. 517 [Law No. 517 of August 4, 1977] (It.).
  25. Long, R., Bridges, E., & Roberts, N. (2026, September 1). The schools white paper 2026: Special educational needs and disability (SEND) reform (Research Briefing CBP-10550). House of Commons Library. https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-10550/
  26. Maryland State Department of Education. (2024, October 23). Individualized education program (IEP) goal writing [Professional learning materials]. https://marylandpublicschools.org/programs/Documents/Special-Ed/Training/Goals-PL-Materials-A.pdf
  27. 19 Tex. Admin. Code § 89.1040 (2026).
  28. Office of the State Superintendent of Education. (n.d.). All about IEP goals: Appropriate, ambitious, and attainable [Family training series]. District of Columbia. https://specialeducation.dc.gov/node/1832606
  29. Oliver, M. (1983). Social work with disabled people. Macmillan.
  30. Oliver, M. (2013). The social model of disability: Thirty years on. Disability & Society, 28(7), 1024–1026. https://doi.org/10.1080/09687599.2013.818773
  31. Parent Educational Advocacy Training Center. (2020, December). Medical diagnosis vs. educational label: Impact on eligibility [Fact sheet]. https://pwcs.edu/userfiles/servers/server_340140/file/special-education/medical-diagnosis-vs-educational-label-in-special-education.pdf
  32. Schneider, W. J., & McGrew, K. S. (2018). The Cattell–Horn–Carroll theory of cognitive abilities. In D. P. Flanagan & E. M. McDonough (Eds.), Contemporary intellectual assessment: Theories, tests, and issues (4th ed., pp. 73–163). Guilford Press.
  33. Skrtic, T. M. (1991). The special education paradox: Equity as the way to excellence. Harvard Educational Review, 61(2), 148–206. https://doi.org/10.17763/haer.61.2.0q702751580h0617
  34. Tex. Educ. Code Ann. § 29.004 (West 2026).
  35. Texas Education Agency. (n.d.). Bluebonnet Learning math grade 1 [Instructional materials quality review]. https://im.tea.texas.gov/programs/bluebonnet-learning-math-grade-1
  36. Texas Education Agency. (2024). Adopted amendments to 19 TAC §§ 89.1011, 89.1040, 89.1050, 89.1055, and 89.1131 [Adopted rule, effective July 30, 2024]. https://tea.texas.gov/about-tea/laws-and-rules/commissioner-rules-tac/coe-adopted/24-07-89-1011.pdf
  37. Texas Education Agency. (2026). Adopted amendments to 19 TAC §§ 89.1005, 89.1040, 89.1075, 89.1121, and 89.1125; repeal of §§ 89.1092 and 89.1094; and new §§ 89.1092 and 89.1094 [Adopted rule]. https://tea.texas.gov/laws-and-rules/commissioner-rules-tac/coe-adopted/26-09-89-1005.pdf
  38. Turnage, L. (2020). Out of sight, out of mind: Rural special education and the limitations of the IDEA. Columbia Journal of Law and Social Problems, 54(1), 1–46. https://jlsp.law.columbia.edu/wp-content/blogs.dir/213/files/2020/11/Vol54-Turnage.pdf
  39. Union of the Physically Impaired Against Segregation. (1976). Fundamental principles of disability. https://disability-studies.leeds.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/40/library/UPIAS-fundamental-principles.pdf
  40. U.S. Department of Education. (2017, December 7). Questions and answers (Q&A) on U.S. Supreme Court case decision Endrew F. v. Douglas County School District Re-1. https://sites.ed.gov/idea/files/qa-endrewcase-12-07-2017.pdf
  41. U.S. Department of Education, Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative Services. (2015, November 16). Dear colleague letter on FAPE and alignment with grade-level content standards. https://sites.ed.gov/idea/idea-files/osep-dear-colleague-letter-on-free-and-appropriate-public-education-fape/
  42. U.S. Government Accountability Office. (2026, January 29). Department of Education: Full costs and savings estimate needed for reduction-in-force and restructuring of the Office for Civil Rights (GAO-26-108320). https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-26-108320
  43. Warnock, M. (Chair). (1978). Special educational needs: Report of the Committee of Enquiry into the Education of Handicapped Children and Young People. HMSO. https://www.educationengland.org.uk/documents/warnock/warnock1978.html